The cost of AI data centers with Rachel Havrelock: How can we preserve fresh water?

THIS IS UIC OFFICIAL PODCAST logo
This is UIC
The cost of AI data centers with Rachel Havrelock: How can we preserve fresh water?
Loading
/

In this episode, Grace Khachaturian sits down with Rachel Havrelock, professor in UIC’s College of Liberal Arts and Sciences and director of the UIC Freshwater Lab. Havrelock reflects on a healing childhood experience at Lake Huron that sparked a lifelong connection to water and inspired her work protecting the Great Lakes. Throughout the episode, she discusses the growing strain AI data centers place on freshwater resources, the potential solutions and shares practical ways people can help protect water in their own communities. 

Key takeaways:  

  • Hyperscale data centers require significant water for cooling, with some using as much as a medium-sized town. 
  • The growing water demands of data centers highlight the need for smarter water use, including wastewater reuse. 
  • Everyday choices, from knowing where your water comes from to what goes down the drain, can make a real difference in protecting our freshwater resources. 

Biography

University of Illinois Chicago professor Rachel Havrelock directs The Freshwater Lab. The nonprofit research and advocacy organization designs water infrastructure and governance initiatives for the Great Lakes watershed, publicizes information about the state of regional water and trains the next generation of leaders in water stewardship through internships at water and environmental organizations. The Freshwater Lab produced “From Waste to Water,” a report outlining possibilities for water recycling in Illinois, and the digital storytelling sites Freshwater Stories and The Backward River. Havrelock is a leading proponent of water recycling in Great Lake states, and The Freshwater Lab’s innovative work on water infrastructure and economic development has been frequently highlighted in the media.  

Rachel Havrelock. (Photos: Jenny Fontaine/UIC)

Show notes

Transcript

Grace Khachaturian  0:00   

Welcome to This Is UIC, the official podcast of the University of Illinois Chicago. I’m your host, Grace Khachaturian. With each episode, we’re making known the stories of our people, where they come from and how they’re leading the way to create and inspire a better world. This is UIC. 

Grace Khachaturian  0:23   

Today on the podcast, we’re joined by Rachel Haverlock, a professor at UIC and director of the Freshwater Lab. Rachel, so glad to have you with us. 

Rachel Havrelock  0:32   

Great to be here. 

Grace Khachaturian  0:33   

So I know that you have made quite the name for yourself when it comes to water and your care for it, especially here in the UIC community in Chicago. Help us understand who you are a little bit. Tell us your why. 

Rachel Havrelock  0:47   

Well, I am a Great Lakes person. I grew up in this remarkable watershed and have been so privileged to make it my home and have my career here in Chicago. And I will never be able to, you know, shake those images of my mind growing up amidst  the beaches of the Great Lakes. And there, on the one hand, this remarkable horizon of fresh water would be before us that just suggested so many possibilities for the future. And then there’s the feeling that that evokes on all the people at the beach. So, you know, no matter those tensions and fears and problems that are very, very real in daily life, there’s a way in which I think when people get to the beach, that eases a little bit, and we have, and I certainly experience that kind of oneness with each other, and also that oneness with the water. And that was something that just stayed inside me for my whole life. 

To an even more personal level, I experienced an accident as a child, and no one ever told me. I’m very glad, but the diagnosis was that I would not be able to walk unaided in the future. And so that was, you know, the, the reality. You know, crutches and braces and adapting to that. And it just so happened that one night I woke up still at home and I forgot about everything and was able to walk. And, you know, then I looked down and realized what had happened and collapsed on the ground and called out to my parents, who kind of couldn’t believe what had transpired. And their first instinct before going to any doctor was to go to the shore of Lake Huron.  

It was March, but so beautiful at the beach. And it’s very vivid, and in my mind and even in my muscles, of that process of walking down the beach with my brace, then with my crutch, then holding the hands of my parents, and ultimately being barefoot in the sand with those cold waters splashing on my feet. And, you know, this was this very profound moment of learning to walk again. And I will always see Lake Huron as playing a role in that healing and being there and, and helping me through that. And it was a kind of a moment of promise, of gratitude for the different ways that the lake provides healing and, and sustenance and possibility. But they also need us in turn. And so, so much of my life’s work has been kind of reciprocating that healing and care by being aware of these remarkable waters, what they give us and also how much attention and, and protection they need from us. 

Grace Khachaturian  4:11   

Yeah, that’s a pretty profound story that would absolutely impact a trajectory of a life and your life’s work. And, you know, I know that when we go to the beach or to a lake, many people gravitate to that space because of that feeling that it evokes that you mentioned. I love that reciprocal relationship of they take care of us, we take care of them.  

So I know you mentioned this a little bit. Talk to us how that childhood experience kind of guided your way into your current work. 

Rachel Havrelock  4:43   

Yeah, that experience guided my current way. You know, realizing that, ideally, our work with water, our use of water, you know, all the ways we interact with it, you know, hopefully there are elements of respect and love and, and recognition there. And that, I think, is the basis. But I’m also a researcher, and so there are many other elements which impact our water. And we can take, you know, any given societal decision: how we grow food, how we deliver and distribute water to different communities, what kind of industries we attract, and what kind of allowances we give them for waste. So every single one of these decisions at every scale, right? The individual, the neighborhood, the municipal, the state, the binational, the industrial. Every scale impacts the nature of that water, its quantity and quality. And that quantity and quality of water, in turn, impacts us, right? Our health, our economy, our security, our safety.  

The Freshwater Lab involves incorporating all these different communities and endeavors and industries, and seeing, right, what we’re collectively putting in and what we’re getting back, and, and where we need to change. So this is to say, my lab certainly deeply values and relies on scientific inquiry. But we also, in starting the Freshwater Lab, you know, looked around and we noticed that there wasn’t an initiative, a research initiative around the Great Lakes that was really rooted in those human experiences and building up better policies, better infrastructure, better communication about our water by really rooting it in these kinds of human experiences. 

Grace Khachaturian  6:54   

At what point did you take this passion and make it more of a collective effort into Freshwater Lab?   

Rachel Havrelock  7:02   

Yeah, it, it was, there was a little bit of a loop. As I said, I grew up around the Great Lakes region. My first area of research was actually in the Middle East, so I had a very, very different experience of debilitating water scarcity. And so, well before we saw the same phenomenon unfurl, begin to unfurl in North America, you know, I saw rivers disappearing and communities without available water. And the kinds of conflict that, you know, aren’t entirely driven by water, but how water can be an element of peacemaking and also an element of conflict.  

So I, I really cut my teeth in some much more difficult water circumstances, and also much tenser and conflict region, more conflict-ridden region of the world. And I think that my personal love and care for water was really amplified when I saw the negative effects that can arise of having too little, of having water that is contaminated to the point of being unusable.  

So the Freshwater Lab came into being in a process of really probing what we, in a relatively abundant watershed, could learn from water-scarce places in the world, and what we, in a place with really strong and robust history of legislation and watershed governance, what we might be able to give other parts of the world. So that was that comparative work was the seed that grew into the Freshwater Lab. 

Grace Khachaturian  9:04   

That’s a great perspective to drive work. What would you say is the current status of our water? 

Rachel Havrelock  9:10   

The current status of water in the Great Lakes, and maybe we’ll take Lake Michigan in particular, being a city on the lake, is that, on the one hand, we have a potentially really, really bright future. Over 20% of the fresh water that flows on Earth moves through the Great Lakes watershed. That is a tremendous statistic. When we are in a time when aquifers are collapsing beneath us, rivers are no longer running to their terminal points and many, many lakes are drying rapidly, or, you know, really choking because of harmful algal blooms. So there’s tremendous possibility here, but that potential isn’t a given, right?  

If we sit back and accept the status quo, we are not going to achieve that potential dream of being an oasis in a dry world, because, you know, we too have our challenges that come with warming. Because of warming, we are experiencing fewer days when the Great Lakes freeze, sometimes no days when the Great Lakes freeze. And a freezing lake does a remarkable thing. It caps the water. And it slows evaporation. So without that ice, evaporation accelerates, also into a warmer atmosphere. And, you know, we know the law: Everything that comes up must come down. So we are seeing that water return, return to us in phenomenon that are not even called rainstorms anymore. They’re called rain events. So, what’s a rain event? A rain event is when high volumes of precipitation fall in an abbreviated time period, and they overwhelm the built environment and they overwhelm our capacity to store it.  

So again, the Great Lakes are tremendous, and they have so many gifts to give, and they can sustain us, and we can absorb industries and agriculture and people. I mean, you know, we, we really could be a new global center in all the best ways. But here, too, we have to make some pretty rapid changes, not only in our design, in our infrastructure, in our allocations, but, you know, also in our thinking. 

Grace Khachaturian  11:59   

So one topic that you hear, I feel like, around kitchen tables and with friends, it’s just a trending topic is AI data centers and water.  

Rachel Havrelock  12:10   

It’s a time of big rainstorms and maybe even bigger data centers. So, generative AI and related technological advances require like kind of a whole new thing, which is the hyperscale data center. And if you think about, you know, even your own computer after a couple hours of use gets hot, right? The fan goes on. You know, multiply that with massive, massive servers, right, generating all of this data. And we get to the cooling problem at hyperscale data centers. Now, one thing we have to say is whether it’s energy cooling or water cooling, really, really significant volumes of water are necessary. Some hyperscale data centers can use the same amount of water as a medium-sized town. So the water implications of AI data centers are tremendous. It hits really hard in water-scarce places.  

Grace Khachaturian  13:23   

So, for the water that’s being used for data centers, are we using just like fresh water, or to what you’re mentioning, can we use a different type of water? 

Rachel Havrelock  13:31   

Currently, data centers in the state of Illinois, it’s hard to get a hold of this information because it’s shrouded in a lot of non-disclosure agreements, which many communities are objecting to. But it seems that over 90% of data centers are actually using treated drinking water. The other ones are relying on source water. So that means the most valuable elements, right, on Earth, treated drinking water, is being supplied to data centers at very, very, very low rates at exactly the moment when this element is becoming increasingly scarce. One, one phrase that we use is don’t give drinking water to robots, because it illustrates, right, the absurdity of this scenario immediately. And if we keep doing that, right, the, the possibility I mentioned earlier of the Great Lakes being that oasis that can absorb many different industries, additional agriculture, community, people, right? The more we allocate to a single thirsty industry, the further and further away that dream of being an oasis and a haven falls. 

Grace Khachaturian  14:57   

Does the geographical placement of data centers play a role in this? Of where that water is coming from or what type of water it’s receiving? 

Rachel Havrelock  15:08   

It should. You’re, you’re already into our call for better comprehensive planning. It absolutely should, but it really doesn’t. As it stands right now, most data centers choose their location based on a few factors, none of which have anything to do with water. How cheap is the land? How close are they to the fiber optic network, right? And how close are they to population-dense places that are going to be users of this? So the question of water is not factoring into the siting of data centers, which is, it’s a big signal, I think, to all of us. It certainly is to us at the Freshwater Lab that we are not pricing or valuing water appropriately. 

Grace Khachaturian  16:04   

I would imagine that our use of these data centers isn’t going to decrease at all. So what can we do? What’s the solution here? 

Rachel Havrelock  16:15   

A lot of things could still happen with data centers. I, in my life and historical reading, I’ve been going to a lot of public meetings about data centers, right? I’m, I’m there to talk about water. But I have, I have never seen the American public stake such a passionate claim to its water. So it’s a very, very interesting moment, right? To see people across the political spectrum, right, across so many different geographies, you know, really weighing in on what they want in their communities and how they want industry to interact with them. And that has come, like we are at a really interesting, burgeoning moment of people noticing, paying attention to their water, asking questions, claiming it. It’s really exciting.  

So, again, whether data centers, you know, expand and are everywhere or not, we have a position at the Freshwater Lab that whether generative AI or any new industry locating in the region should not run on drinking water. We need this drinking water for people. But we also need to make sure that we have ecosystem stability and we do not tap the Great Lakes, right, into non-regeneration.  

So here’s our, our big project is one of water recycling, also known as water reuse. So let’s take the, the Chicago land, the Cook County example, because it, you know, it really is a prime opportunity. All of the water that begins in Lake Michigan that we use in the region for drinking, all our domestic uses, our industrial uses,, we send that down the drain. That’s modern life, right? That’s where water goes. And our drains are combined. So that means they meet underground with the storm drains where all that precipitation that falls also gathers. And we label this, you know, first it’s called stormwater and wastewater. But once it’s combined, modern life calls that all wastewater. And in Cook County, that water gets stored in these massive reservoirs and gaping tunnels called TARP or the Deep Tunnel System, and then it’s held. It’s staggered to our wastewater treatment plants. It’s treated to a high level. And then all this water that the taxpayers have paid to store and to treat to high levels, we still treat it like waste, and we’re sending it out of state.  

This is not only  valuable, perfectly good fresh water, but it also, right, we are also missing massive opportunities to bring this water into productive use in ways that can support economy and development. And so the Freshwater Lab, since 2020, and water recycling is something in long practice in drought-plagued countries, but also in California and increasingly in the American West where communities are recycling this water for drinking, OK. Great Lakes people, we don’t need to drink it so long as we recycle this water for industrial uses.  

Now, I’m not saying only data centers should take this water, but data centers should absolutely and only run on this water. But that is the case with every new industry going forward. And maybe once we get really good, we can even retrofit some of the industries we have right here. So, you know, as data centers are developing, and I leave it to communities and their elected leaders to figure that out, whether they’re going to be developed or not, but when they are, right? No data center should run on drinking water, especially in Illinois where we are sending away, right? We are paying to divert fresh water that could be solving the problems of scarcity and development for us right now. 

Our phrase at the Freshwater Lab is no more single-use water, right? Water is far too precious to ever be treated like trash. 

Grace Khachaturian  44:13   

If not addressed, if we continue in the way that we have, then will these data centers use all of our water? It is 

Rachel Havrelock  44:19   

highly possible that left unaddressed, if things go as they are, Illinois would be among the states that would face potential water shortages, scarcity, as well as rising costs because of such high allocations of drinking water to data centers? So, if things just go with nothing done, we could be in a very, very difficult to. Situation where communities inland whose groundwater is failing could look to Lake Michigan for drinking water and would be told no because that same drinking water had been directed to hyperscale data centers. 

Grace Khachaturian  21:15   

Are there things in our day-to-day lives that we can think about of how to be smart water consumers and aware water users? 

Rachel Havrelock  21:25   

Yeah, every scale and every interaction with water has an impact. So there is no scale, right, which is too small or insignificant. We, the Freshwater Lab, has a digital storytelling site about Lake Michigan. But one exercise we have on there, we call it Source Path People, and you can do it on your own or you can get together with a with a group of friends. And it’s just a series of questions where people can learn about the source of their drinking water, and knowing these things. It’s so eye-opening, right? And not usually like part of any of our education, but it is this really, really vital form of local knowledge.  

And then, you know, everything we send down that drain matters, and so paying attention, right? Our laundry detergent, you know, what’s in it. This ends up back in bodies of water. You know, anything we’re sending down being drain saying about that, and just like even spreading the word has big impacts. And, you know, one other kind of momentous thing that people can do is, you know, these rain events, they hit our roofs and our sidewalks, and, you know, any kind of land people might have in an urban area. And so what we do out there matters, right? Enlisting trees to help us absorb rain and capture that in a rain barrel that we can then use to, like, you know, hose down the sidewalk or wash a car. That’s a little, you know, mini form of water recycling. 

Grace Khachaturian  23:09   

How has your personal relationship with water changed from the child at the beach of Lake Huron to now? How has your relationship changed? 

Rachel Havrelock  23:20   

As a child, and, you know, everything that Lake Erie and the Detroit River and Lake Huron, you know, everything those bodies of water were to me, you know, was, was also possible because I got to grow up after the Clean Water Act. So, right, had I been born 10 years earlier, it would have been a very different prospect to, you know, walk barefoot with a scar, or, you know, plunge in the water for as long as I possibly could. You know, I didn’t, I didn’t know that as a child, right? I, I didn’t know, you know, how much these collective decisions impact the water. It was unfathomable that, you know, the possibility that water could be gone. I think so much decision making in the world, particularly in the Western world, so much decision making was premised on, like, water will never go away; it will always be here. And, you know, these are and have always been false assumptions. And we are, you know, standing at a juncture where we’re living with the upshot of those decisions. And we need to think about modes of repair and remediation.   

Grace Khachaturian  24:44   

Well, Rachel, I’m so grateful for your time here today with us. I’m sure the information that you shared will be eye-opening for many and a catalyst for impact. Before we close out our time, if you were to pick a song that best represents your story, what song would you pick? 

Rachel Havrelock  25:01   

Jamila Woods’ song. It’s “LSD for Lakeshore Drive.” 

[MUSIC: “LSD” by Jamila Woods] 

And the chorus says, “If you wanna love me, you better love the lake. 

Grace Khachaturian  25:59   

Very fitting. I love it. Well, thank you so much for your time here today. We’re so grateful. 

Grace Khachaturian  25:37   

Learn more about Rachel Havrelock in the show notes at today.uic.edu.

[MUSIC: “LSD” by Jamila Woods] 

Thanks for listening to This Is UIC, the official podcast of the University of Illinois Chicago. As Chicago’s only public research university, we’re letting the world know what we know. Until next time, visit today.uic.edu.